Replace or Repair a Cracked Windshield? Find the Best Solution



At some point, almost every driver will encounter the inconvenience of a cracked windshield, a common issue resulting from various incidents such as minor accidents, debris impact, or
abrupt temperature shifts. The dilemma often lies in deciding whether to repair or replace the damaged windshield. This decision typically depends on a few significant factors, including the size, location, and severity of the crack, the vehicle type, and the cost implications. Each option, repair, or replacement has its advantages and disadvantages, which we will thoroughly discuss to help determine the optimal solution.


Deciding When to Repair or Replace a Damaged Windshield


Firstly, the kind and degree of damage significantly dictate the choice. Small chips or cracks, usually no larger than a quarter, are often repairable. Windshield repair technology has
advanced, allowing professionals to inject resin into minor cracks, which when hardened, restores the windshield’s structural strength and transparency. This method is relatively quick, economical, and often possible at your location.


However, extensive cracks or chips, particularly those reaching the windshield’s edge, might necessitate a full replacement. Also, the damage’s position matters. If it impedes the driver’s direct vision, even a minor crack or chip could warrant replacement. A repair might not restore the windshield to a perfect condition, and any remaining slight distortion could impact driver visibility.


Whether to repair or replace a cracked windshield largely depends on the size, location, and severity of the damage. Here are some general guidelines:


Size of the Crack or Chip: Typically, if the chip is smaller than the size of a quarter and the crack is less than three inches long, it can usually be repaired. However, larger damages often call for a windshield replacement.


Location of the Crack or Chip: If the crack is in the driver’s line of sight, even if it’s small, it might be recommended to replace the windshield because the repair process can cause minor distortions that can affect visibility. Cracks at the edge of the windshield tend to spread quickly and undermine the structural integrity of the glass, so replacement is usually the safer option in these cases.


Severity of the Damage: If the damage penetrates both layers of the windshield or reaches into the inner layer of auto glass, a replacement is usually necessary.


The Type of Windshield


The type of vehicle also influences the decision. Some luxury vehicles have windshields featuring sophisticated technologies like heads-up displays, rain sensors, or lane departure
warnings. Repairing such a windshield could risk damaging these systems, hence replacement might be the superior option.


Cost of the windshield


From a cost perspective, windshield repair is undeniably the less expensive choice, often costing considerably less than a full replacement. Many insurance companies even waive the deductible for windshield repairs, making it essentially cost-free for the policyholder. Yet, cost should not be the only determinant in your decision. A cracked windshield can critically undermine vehicle safety. The windshield provides significant structural support, particularly in a rollover accident. If the damage is too severe for a repair to restore this support, the additional cost of replacement is justified for the safety of the vehicle’s occupants.


Durability of Repair Versus Replacement


The longevity of the repair compared to replacement is another crucial consideration. A repair can last for years, given that the initial damage was minor, and the repair was performed by a competent technician. However, the repaired area might crack again under extreme weather conditions. Conversely, a replacement will have the lifespan of a new windshield, assuming
careful use and absence of incidents.


Environmental Factors


An often-ignored factor is the environmental impact. Repairing, instead of replacing, saves resources and decreases the number of discarded windshields in landfills. If you’re
environmentally conscious, a repair might be the preferred choice, as long as it doesn’t compromise safety and quality.


Peace of Mind


Practical factors aside, peace of mind plays a role too. A small, repaired crack might not pose a safety risk, but it can serve as an ongoing reminder of the windshield’s vulnerability. A new windshield, though more expensive, could provide a sense of security and restoration that a repair might not.




Choosing between repairing and replacing a cracked windshield depends on numerous factors. Small, surface-level cracks are typically repairable in a cost-effective and quick manner. In
contrast, large cracks or those affecting the driver’s sightline or the vehicle’s advanced systems often necessitate a complete replacement. While cost factors are crucial, safety should always be the primary concern. Consulting with a professional auto glass technician is always advisable to make an informed decision. They can evaluate the damage and guide you to the best course of action.


If you’re dealing with a cracked windshield, Auto Glass America can assist you in deciding whether to repair or replace it. They will collaborate with you to find a solution that fits both your needs and budget.

Schedule Your Glass Repair Today

Schedule Your Repair
AGA Man in front of Vehicle

Schedule Your Glass Repair Today

Schedule Your Repair
AGA Man in front of Vehicle